Stardew Valley: Should You Choose The Fruit Bat Or Mushroom Cave?

The choice between Fruit Bats and Mushrooms is a compelling one for , with both options offering clear benefits. However, the Farm Cave can only support one of the two, and the upgrade is irreversible, much like ’s choice between the Rancher and Tiller professions. This will have a lasting impact on a farm and the produce people can easily obtain with it, and as such, the decision is worth some careful consideration beforehand.

No matter the layout of a Farm, the Cave can be found along its northern edge. Although initially empty, local scientist Demetrius will approach the player with an offer after they have earned a total of 25,000g; in order to advance his research, he will outfit the Cave to support either Mushrooms or Fruit Bats. Either option grants access to produce, specifically Fruit and Mushrooms, with the exact types that spawn being randomized. Both bring their perks and downsides, although it is worth noting that neither option prevents the other’s produce from being obtained through alternative means.

If Fruit Bats are chosen to fill the Farm Cave, then the mammals will begin randomly leaving fruit and berries in the Cave at night. These can even be out of season, making Fruit Bats an excellent option for those aiming to make plenty of Artisan Goods. They also contribute to the Artisan Bundle found in the Community Center’s Pantry, which both rewards people with a Keg and puts the Greenhouse one step closer to restoration. These Fruits even make for pleasant gifts for Stardew Valley’s other residents, helping farmers to quickly build up good relationships with their neighbors.

Fruit Bats can leave Cherries, Pomegranates, Peaches, Apples, Oranges, and Apricots, as well as Spice Berries, Wild Plums, Blackberries, and Salmonberries.

On the other hand, choosing Mushrooms causes Common Mushrooms, Red Mushrooms, Purple Mushrooms, Morels, and Chanterelles to begin growing in the Cave. Similar to the Fruit Bats’ Fruits, the exact Mushrooms produced are