Helldivers 2 balance lead says the "don't nerf, only buff" approach is a horrible idea as the community reacts to top weapon nerfs

As the Helldivers 2 community learns a whole new meta in the wake of a major balance patch that took a hammer to favorites like the railgun and personal shield, one balance lead from developer Arrowhead has advised players to learn to embrace nerfs rather than constantly asking exclusively for buffs.

"I have since the game released seen many who say 'Don’t Nerf, only Buff' and other similar ideas," writes head of product testing Patrik Lasota, who's responsible for feedback and game balance. "However, as a designer I can tell you this is not a great idea, but I understand where the sentiment comes from. All too often in the games industry the core fantasy, and what makes a weapon feel good and fun, is ignored for the sake of Balance. 

"I believe players are scared of nerfs, because it will ruin the fantasy of a weapon, ruin their fun," Lasota adds. "It is extra important to us to tread carefully so that we don’t ruin fantasy and fun when we do nerfs. We hope you, our players, will tell us when we cross that line inadvertently." 

Has this patch crossed that line? It's too early to say, but at first blush, it doesn't seem like it. A lot of the doom and gloom feels like normal knee-jerk nerf reactions, which are totally fair and expected, but I'm already seeing a lot of people eagerly embrace the new and realize that their nerfed favorites can still get the job done. In my experience weathering nerfs across many games over many years, that's a very good sign. 

This message echoes what another dev from Arrowhead said immediately following the release of the patch: "Having your favorite toy nerfed absolutely sucks." The point, Arrowhead has reiterated, is "to give you a wide range of weapon choices, where each gun has its purpose and none is strictly better than another." When everyone is railgunning everything into next week because the gun is, to put it mildly, nucking futs, that's hard to manage. And to Lasota's point, a never-ending stream of buffs will inevitably